At a recent clinic, the client who had been
diagnosed with Raynaud’s syndrome; a circulatory disorder effecting blood
supply to the extremities, was given the suggestion of introducing green tea
for its thermogenic properties. Given
how much I like green tea I thought I would dig a bit further on understanding
this concept. As with many nutritional
things, the answers were not straight-forward, and my research took me on a bit
of journey.
Thermogensis very simply is the production
of heat in the body and also increases metabolism. It can be triggered by a number of different
factors, Geissler and Powers identify four forms (Geissler et al, 2009):
- Cold induced
- Diet induced
- Psychological
- Drug induced

Cold induced thermogenesis has two forms:
shivering and non-shivering, however, in both cases it is an involuntary
function of the body intended to generate heat and raise the body’s core
temperature when exposed to a cold environment.
As such cold induced thermogeneis is a key part of the body temperature regulation. Non-shivering thermogensis and its
relationship with brown adipose tissue is coming under the research microscope,
since it may provide some answers for weight management and obesity. Brown adipose tissue has been described as a
furnace, consuming calories to generate heat.
Until recently it was thought the humans lost much of their brown
adipose tissue after infancy, but studies have shown that some brown adipose
tissue is retained in adulthood although how much depends on your sex, age and
weight. The question for scientists is
whether this brown fat can be safely activated in humans. Can it be activiated only by cold? Or do other substances activate it? If activiated in humans would it simply
induce us to eat more rather than lose weight?
As yet there are no definitive answers (Kolata, 2009).
The metabolism increasing properties of
thermogenesis and the use of diet induced thermogenesis (DIT) in weight loss
and management has been under the spotlight for sometime. In simple terms, by requiring more energy to
digest these foods; the offset to the calorific value of the food is higher and
therefore consuming these foods can assist with weight loss. At the macronutrient level, the thermogenic
hierarchy is said to be alcohol, protein, carbohydrate and fat (Westerterp,
2004), which gives some insight into the premise of high protein diets such as Aktins and
Dukan. However, it is important to note
that DIT only constitutes between 5-15% of daily energy expenditure
(Westerterp, 2004). The more variable
component of daily energy expenditure is Physical Activity (PA) which coupled
with overall calorie intake is likely to have a more significant impact on
weight loss.
Things become more interesting when you
look at psychological and drug induced thermogenesis since these tend to tap
into the sympathetic nervous system (SNS) or our fight or flight response. Psychological thermogenesis is related with
stress, which is inextricably linked to the sympathetic nervous system. When triggered by a fright or a stress the
adrenal glands release the hormones adrenaline and noradrenaline, which induce
a cascade of responses in our body as it prepares for fight or flight. The primary response is from the cardiovascular system which will increase heart rate, and therefore blood flow to the
periphery of the body. This activity
tends to increase body heat and may induce sweating and may in part account for
why people under long term stress may experience significant weight loss. However, the SNS will also suppress appetite,
since you are unlikely to want to consider food, when you think you might
become the next meal for a sabre-tooth tiger.
The drugs (or stimulants) in drug induced
thermogenesis can artificially stimulate the SNS to produce thermogenesis. Caffeine falls squarely into this category, so
while that after dinner coffee may in the short term increase the body heat and
metabolism, it also stimulates body responses that longer term are not so
positive. The stimulation of SNS will
also prompt the adrenals, kidneys, and bladder functions into increased
urination. Dehydration resulting from
increased urination cools the body temperature and a lack of regulated blood
flow to the intestines reduces the warmth needed for proper digestion, which is
already lowered since digestion is not a necessity during fight or
flight. Finally, caffeine will stimulate
the liver to release stored glycogen (sugar) molecules to provide fuel for
flight or fight, but the liver will need to replenish its glycogen store, which
can then result in strong cravings for sugar (Gagne, 2008).

So why propose green tea, which also
contains caffeine for its thermogenic qualities if overall it could have a
cooling effect? In addition to caffeine,
green tea is rich in two additional components: catechins and theanine. Catechins are a class of phytochemicals which
are potent antioxidants and also inhibit inflammation. Their potential disease fighting capability
from cardiovascular disease to cancer is the subject of considerable research. Other studies have suggested that catechins,
in particular Epigallocatechin gallate (EGCG) contained in green tea, amplifies
the thermogenic effect of caffeine (Dulloo et al, 2000). This is where Theanine,
another component of green tea comes into play. Theanine is an amino acid and an antioxidant,
but more significantly acts as an antagonist to caffeine. The natural balance of caffeine and Theanine
in green tea offers all the calming effects of Theanine but also offsets the agitating
effects of caffeine. In addition, the
calming effects of Theanine do not include any drowsiness or impairment of
clarity of thought (Owen et al, 2008).
Thermogenesis is a very natural process
within the body and can be triggered in a number of ways. Not all of these mechanisms are entirely
positive and therefore caution should be applied, if seeking to increase
metabolism for weight loss or management.
However, if you feel a chill and looking for some additional warmth from
your food, consider adding some of these thermogenic foods:
- Cayenne pepper and other hot
peppers are one of the most commonly known thermogenic foods. Hot peppers are thermogenic because they
contain capsaicin, which has both satiating effect as well as increasing DIT (Mishra & Pratt, 2012). Another theory as to why
cayenne helps with weight loss is similar to the reasons behind curry’s
effectiveness: it’s difficult for most people to overeat hot or spicy food.
- Black peppercorns: contain peperine which has a similar effect to capsaicin.
- Mustard Seed: in Ayurveda, mustard seeds are recommended for digestive problems, because of heat they generate. Mustard plasters are also indicated for respiratory and circulatory problems, helping to stimulate blood flow and soothe inflammation. More recently, a study conducted by Dr Jeya Henry at Oxford Brooks University found that a small amount of hot mustard – less than one teaspoon – can boost metabolism by 20-25%.
- Ginger: Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) holds that ginger “restores devastated yang” and “expels cold”. A recent pilot study also showed enhanced thermogenesis and reduced feelings of hunger with ginger consumption.
- The three Cs: Cardamom, Cinnamon and Cloves: are considered warming spices and can also increase metabolism, improve digestion and nutrient absorption. This nicely brings us back to tea since these three spices are the key spices in chai tea.

The following Masala Chai recipe is taken from Madhur Jaffrey's Indian Cooking (1983) p. 196:
1-1/2 cups water
1 inch stick of cinnamon
8 cardomom pods
8 whole cloves
2/3 cup milk
6 tsp. sugar (or to taste)
3 teaspoons any unperfumed loose black tea
Put 1-1/2 cups water in saucepan. Add the cinnamon, cardomom, and cloves and bring to a boil. Cover, turn heat to low and simmer for 10 minutes. Add the milk and sugar and bring to a simmer again. Throw in the tea leaves, cover, and turn ff the heat. After 2 minutes, strain the tea into two cups and serve immediately.
References
Dulloo AG, Seydoux J, Girardier L, Chantre P & Vandermander J.
(2000). Green tea and thermogenesis: interactions between catechin-polyphenols,
caffeine and sympathetic activity. The International Journal of Obesity.
24 pp. 22-258.
Gagne, S. (2008). The
Energetics of Cooling Foods?. Available:
http://www.macrobiotics.co.uk/articles/coolingfoods.htm. Last accessed 7th June
2013.
Geissler CA & Powers HJ (2009). Fundamentals of Human Nutrition. China.
Churchill Livingstone. pp.15-16
Owen GN, Parnell H, De Bruin EA, Rycroft JA. (2008). The combined
effects of L-theanine and caffeine on cognitive performance and mood. Nutritional
Neuroscience. 11 (4), pp.193-198